Turf toe gets no respect. Let's take a closer look at the causes of turf toe and see how you can treat it more effectively.
- Turf toe is actually a form of hallux limitus.
- Hallux limitus is typically described as pain and progressive decrease in the range of motion of the first metatarsal phalangeal joint (MPJ).
- The onset of hallux limitus is due to the following:
Functional hallux limitus - biomechanical function that results in metatarsus primus elevatus as well as subsequent repetitive jamming of the initial MPJ.
- Direct physical injury - injury to the articular cartilage or subchondral bone.
- These injuries may be due impaction injuries or hyperextension/flexion of the first MPJ.
Other conditions - synovitis, crystal deposition diseases such as gout, systemic osteoarthritis, external physical influences such as Dupytren's contracture, etc.
But before we go any further, we need to understand that the terms turf toe and hallux limitus aren't really synonymous. The fundamental difference between the two phrases is the patient population that they affect. Turf toe is a term used in athletic bags talking about any damage of the great toe shared. Consequently, discussions concerning turf toe may focus on the first two causes of hallux limitus mentioned above; functional hallux limitus and direct physical injury. On the other hand, when we discuss hallux limitus, we're actually referring to a broader, non-athletic' patient population as well as need to include all three causes of hallux limitus.
Think of turf toe (hallux limitus) as an isolated case of osteoarthritis limited to the first MPJ. Whether the injury is acute or due to repetitive loading, the effect is lots that is put on the subchondral bone that is greater than the bone tissue can tolerate. As the damage progresses, a series of micro fractures will develop in the subchondral bone. The typical soft spongy character of the metaphyseal bone changes to become brittle and hard. The result is that the articular cartilage looses its' fundamental support and becomes susceptible to injury. Juxtachondral eburnation, osteophytes, lipping, spurring; call them what you like, but what you see on your x-ray is the slow progressive destruction of the joint.
What's the actual physical change that takes place in the joint with turf toe? As an easy analogy, consider the changes that takes place when an apple falls from a height and is damaged. The skin of the apple appears intact but the underlying pulp is damaged. In the case of turf toe (hallux limitus), think of the skin of the apple because the cartilage of the joint and the damaged pulp of the apple is the subchondral bone. Moderate cases of turf toe (hallux limitus), result in little damage to the subchondral bone and can merely exhibit signs of inflammatory change within the shared.
Most Authors Would Refer to These Cases as Stage One Turf Toe (Hallux Limitus)
More severe cases result in damage to the joint surface, the subchondral bone or each. These are the stage two and three cases of turf toe (hallux limitus) that show visible change on x-ray. As the subchondral bone gets increasingly damaged, this will create a good uneven helping surface for the cartilage. An increase in activity results in uneven loading of the combined due to the compression injury of the subchondral bone.
The start of turf toe usually the same? Turf toe that is the result of functional hallux limitus are going to be insidious in onset. Functional hallux limitus will often be seen in younger athletes as they attempt to improve their activity. It may not occur during the first athletic season, or the second, but when it does set out to cause pain, the onset will be more frequent and more severe, various with activity. This profile of onset is simply due to the fact that the athlete is recreating the injury with every step.
Turf Toe Caused by a Direct Injury to the Joint May or May Not be Obvious
Athletes may not remember an incident of pain since they're often distracted by the event or game in which they are involved. The onset of direct injury to the combined may be unexpected, but also may always be insidious becoming increasingly more painful as the season progresses. The joint pain will abate with rest only to recur together with increased activity. It's not unusual to see signs of turf toe resolve in the off season only to recur with renewed exercise.
Treatment of turf toe varies along with the sort of healthcare provider and includes the use of rest, shoe modifications, orthotics, steroid shots and surgery. The success of non-surgical attention will vary with the degree of injury, the rate at which the injury is healing as well as how much osteoarthritis has occurred. We see varying degrees of success with orthotics that promote plantarflexion of the initial ray, effectively treating metatarsus primus elevatus and peroneus longus dysfunction.
Simple Arch Supports can Make a Significant Difference in the Symptoms of Turf Toe
Should our patient not really react to conservative care in a reasonable time period, we are not reluctant to suggest surgical revision to address the problem may it be revisions of the shared defect, shortening of a long first metatarsal or architectural revision of metatarsus primus elevatus. As mentioned before, the clinical appearance of dorsal lipping or visible radiographic changes are suggestive of moderately advanced osteoarthritis, a condition that is only repaired by joint revision or replacement.
When treating turf toe be sure to recognize the fact that there is no nerve innervation in articular cartilage. Pain associated with stage one turf toe (hallux limitus) will be either synovial pain or bone pain. If we all recognize that unpleasant stage one turf toe hallux limitus) may be due to bone pain, we then realize that turf toe should be taken care of aggressively to make sure the long run possibility of the joint.
First MPJ - the big toe joint Metatarsus primus elevatus - a practical or structural position of the first metatarsal First metatarsal - the foot bone making up the proximal part of the large toe joint Hallux - the great toe.
The great toe joint, or first metatarsal joint consists of two bones. The proximal bone is the first metatarsal as well as the distal is named the proximal phalanx or hallux. These two bone move against each other within an up and down motion through what we refer to as the sagital plane. Biomechanics: The motion of the great toe joint is dependant after the plantarflexion of the first metatasal. If the first metatarsal is limitied in its' power to plantarflex, the joint will jam leading to funtional hallux limitus, which as we know is one of the causes of turf toe.
Turf toe that is the result of functional hallux limitus is going to be insidious in onset. Functional hallux limitus will often be seen in youthful sports athletes as they try to increase their activity. It may not occur during the first athletic season, or the second, but when it does set out to hurt, the onset will be more frequent and more severe, varying with activity. This profile of onset is simply due to the fact that the athlete is recreating the injury with every step. Turf toe caused by a direct injury to the joint may or may not be obvious.
- Athletes may not remember an incident of pain since they are often distracted by the event or game in which they're involved.
- The onset of primary injury to the joint could be abrupt, but also may be insidious becoming increasingly more painful as the season progresses.
- The joint pain may diminish with rest only to recur with increased activity.
- It's not unusual to see symptoms of turf toe resolve in the off season only to recur with renewed exercise.
The differential diagnosis of turf bottom includes; ArthitisFracture Gout Joint infection Shared or bone tissue tumor Synovitis.
Lombardi, C.M., Silhanek, A.D., Connolly, F.G., Dennis, L.N.,Keslonsky, A.J. First Metatarsophalangeal Arthrodesis forTreatment of Hallux Rigidus: A Retrospective Study. J. FootSurg. 40:3, 137-143, 2001
Unger, K., Rahimi, F., Bareither, D., Muehleman, C. TheRelationship Among Articular Cartilage Degeneration and BoneChanges of the first Metatarsophalangeal Joint. J. Foot Surg.
Gout and Pseudogout, Joint Pain- Everything You Need To Know- Dr. Nabil Ebraheim
Educational video describing the condition of gout and pseudogout. Become a friend on facebook: http://www.facebook.com/drebraheim Follow me on twitter: ...
Ronconi, P., Monachino, P., Baleanu, P.M.,Favilli, G. DistalOblique Osteotomy of the first Metatarsal for the Correction ofHallux Limitus and also Rigidus Deformity. J. Base Surg. 39:3,
About the Author:Jeffrey a
Oster, DPM, C.Ped is a board certified foot and ankle surgeon. Dr. Oster is also board certified in pedorthics. Dr. Oster is medical director of Myfootshop.com which is in active practice in Granville, Ohio.